Wetherby War Memorial - The Great War 1914 - 1918

Private John Claude Metcalfe

Gunter, R B N
Durrant, C M
Weston, C G
Kelly, K G
Armitage, G J
Durrant, H M L
Hargreaves, J P
March, G
Dukes, W
Fowler, R
Westerman, H
Kirk, J C
Wiggins, T A
Telford, G
Harper, J W
Alexander, H W
Mason, T F
Wilkinson, W
Brown, C
Adkin, J
Barton, F
Hobman, A
Webster, A E
March, E A
Miller, G
Hannan, E
Utley, G
Walker, F
Bygrave, E W
Chapman, E
Varley, N W
Bowen, F J
Byrom, F
Backhouse, S
Dalby, M
Crossland, A
Crossley, J S
Dean, R
Frost, A E
Hodgson, F H
Holt, J
Hood, W H
Hill, W
Kitchen, T
Linfoot, E
Metcalfe, J C
Marsden, J
Pawson, W
Precious, G
Scutt, T G
Wiggins, J
Walker, E
Wood, A
Young, T
Pratt, W
Taylor, H
Dawson, G W
Lister, J
Binge, T
Atack, G
Durham, E F
Precious, G R
Wheelhouse Smith, W
Backhouse, H
Swann, J W
Burnsides, G A
Coles, W
Kelly, H W
Miles, J G
Tapsell, K

"B" Company, 18th (Service) Battalion, West Yorkshire Regiment (2nd Bradford Pals)
Died, 31st August 1917, aged 28 years.

Cemetery: La Targette British Cemetery, Neuville-Saint-Vaast, Pas-de-Calais, Franc
Son of William and Rose Ann Metcalfe of River Cottage, Wetherby.
The Early Years
John Claude Metcalfe was born on the 4th October 1889 at Halifax to parents William, occupation, a Blacksmith, and Rose Ann Metcalfe (nee Ward). John was the second child of this union of marriage, Jenny Metcalfe his sister, being born at Colne, Lancashire, in 1887. The 1891 Census details record that at this juncture the family were residing in premises located at Number 2, Gladstone View, Southowram.
During the intervening years and after relocating to Horsforth near Leeds, a second son was born, Herbert, in 1897, the family now residing at premises located in Back Lane, Horsforth, a terrace of substantial stone built houses. The 1901 Census records that at this period William was still employed as a Blacksmith (Own Account), and that Jenny, only aged 13 years, had found employment as a Textile Dyer no doubt in one of a number of mills situated in the locality.
An analysis of the Electoral Registers for West Yorkshire indicate that the Metcalfe family relocated to Wetherby in the year 1906 originally residing in premises located at Kirk Deighton and then in North Street. By the following year, the family had moved to 'River Cottage,' a quaint house located on the bend of the River Wharfe next to the modern day Tennis and Squash Courts at the foot of Scott Lane.
Up on moving to the flourishing Yorkshire market town of Wetherby, for John it was an opportunity to display his sporting prowess. Joining the Wetherby Junior Football Club as a Left Half-Back, the Secretary being one Joseph Henry Clay, a Newspaper Reporter and resident of Victoria Street, the team played their games on land owned by George Gunter at Heuthwaite, off Walton Road. It is of interest to note the team as it was circa 1906-07, many of the young men ultimately serving in the Great War:-
Stanley Cooper Mellor (Army Cyclist Corps, 62nd Division)
Frank Musgrave
Bertie Arthur Wood (Arthur Wood, Captain & Goalkeeper, 5th West Yorkshire's?)
John Claud Metcalfe (Left Half-Back, 18th West Yorkshire's K.I.A.)
Percy Waterhouse
John Edwin Skirrow (Royal Navy)
Joseph Wiggins (9th West Yorkshire's K.I.A.)
Herbert Ridsdale
William Wharldall (Training Reserve & West Yorkshire's)
George Rothwell Ellis (9th West Yorkshire's)
Fred Tomlinson (5th Lincolns)
Sidney Ridsdale
Lawrence Flynn
Ellis Baxter?
Attracting the affections of a young lady, John married one Edith Wood aged 20 years, the daughter of George Wood, a Tanner of Victoria Street, Wetherby, on November 12th 1910 at Saint James Parish Church. Now employed as a Wood Turner at Westerman's Wood Mill, tragically, Edith died just a few months after their marriage, the cause of death unknown at present. John returned to reside with his parents at 'River Cottage' to continue his employment at the Mill no doubt with a heavy heart.
Upon the outbreak of the Great War and with many young men from Wetherby responding to their country's call, John enlisted in to the British Army in 1915.
As is so often the case, service documents relating to John's military service unfortunately did not survive the bombing of the archives located in London during the Second World War. Amongst Medal Rolls and other documents however, an entry regarding his military service is to be found recorded in the pages of the 'De Ruvigny's Roll Of Honour,' a subscription being apparently required to enter one's details as per 'The National Roll Of Honour.'
The aforementioned entry in 'De Ruvigny' states that John enlisted in to the ranks of the Yorkshire Hussars at York on the 23rd September 1915 however an analysis of serial numbers issued proves his allocation to the Hussars as inaccurate. Initially issued the number 3799, John was then re-numbered to 201568 (West Yorkshire Regiment), the latter number indicating a re-numbering sequence to a Territorial Battalion of the Regiment. Although commonly occuring in 1917, men issued this series of numbers also appear in the ranks of the 1/5th as early as mid 1916. The Medal Rolls record John as formerly serving with the 1/5th Battalion, West Yorkshire Regiment but amongst this allocation of numbers there may be also be found a number of men whose service was conducted with the 2/5th Battalion of the Regiment. It is plausible that initial service was conducted with the 2/5th before being posted to the 1/5th Battalion, the latter, who had been serving on the Western Front since April 1915. In conclusion, a possible enlistment scenario utilising what by the Author is deemed more 'plausible' information contained in the 'De Ruvigny' entry is as follows:-
Enlistment, York, circa Autumn/Winter 1915 under the auspices of the Derby Scheme (i.e. Voluntary Enlistment).
Placed on the Army Reserve and Mobilised in March 1916. (Authors note: It is of interest to note that the War Diary of the 2/5th West Yorkshire's records that on the 8th March 1916, "Drafts of Derby Recruits from ADMINISTRATIVE CENTRE arrived." This 'centre' possibly refers to the Regimental Depot located at York. Source: T.N.A. WO95/3081/1).
Posted overseas to the 1/5th Battalion, West Yorkshire Regiment, June 1916. (Authors note: 94 Other Ranks joined on the 3rd June whilst the battalion were located at Vignacourt. On the 21st, 178 Other Ranks reported at Puchevillers, these men originating from the 1st Garrison Battalion, West Yorkshire Regiment. On the 24th, 34 Other Ranks arrived at Puchevillers from Le Havre and finally on the 26th, 25 Other Ranks joined, these men originating from the 3rd Line Territorial Battalion(s)).
The strength of the 1/5th West Yorkshire's on the 26th June 1916 is recorded as 940 men of all ranks. It is no coincidence that the strength of the battalion was bolstered as the battalion, in division, were about to take their part in the opening day of the Battle of the Somme. Although in support to the attacks of both the 32nd and the 36th (Ulster) Division, the battalion would suffer numerous casualties even though being not directly involved in the attack. For a more detailed narrative of events of the 1st July 1916, the reader may wish to refer to the commemoration of Ernest Walker:-  

Private Ernest Walker

The Opening Day Of The Somme Offensive: The Aftermath

The 1/5th Battalion, West Yorkshire Regiment, Commanding Officer Lieutenant-Colonel Cecil Ernest Wood C.M.G., had gone into action on the 1st July with a fighting strength of 25 officers and 725 Other Ranks, a detachment of remaining officers and men under the command of Captain Donald Paly MacKay being sent to Bouzincourt to replace losses. The War Diary records that during the 1st July, the battalion suffered 3 officers wounded (Second-Lieutenants Bernard Ernest Ablitt, Bernard Edwin Brown and Reginald Frankland White) and in Other Ranks, 5 were killed and 53 wounded. An analysis of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission database now concludes that 12 men were actually killed on this date. Numbering amongst the wounded was one Private Fred Barton, 1451, of the Farm Cottages, Stockeld Park, who received a gun shot wound to his right shoulder and Harry Skelton, 1424, of Bank Street, nature of wounds received unknown.

(Authors note: The battalion were not effectively relieved until the afternoon of the 3rd July and therefore during the 1st/2nd July, to establish the exact dates for casualties proves to be problematic. Primarily, this is due to the actions of a small party under the command of Colonel Wood that had proceeded to the Schwaben Redoubt on the night of the 1st/2nd to ascertain the situation of the 36th (Ulster) Division. No doubt as a result of this operation, Major Frederick Charles Thompson was posted as missing, Lieutenant and Adjutant Rowland Telford Casebourne killed, dates of death recorded as the 2nd July. During the course of this day also, both Lieutenant James Leslie Jameson M.C. and  Second-Lieutenant Arthur Basil Lee were reported as wounded ( both officers subsequently recorded by C.W.G.C. as died on the 2nd July and now commemorated on the Thiepval Memorial). In addition to the deaths of these officers, Second-Lieutenants Robert Edward Hopper, Andrew Daniel Clubb and Wilfrid Dresser? were wounded. In Other Ranks, the War Diary records that 3 men were killed and 50 wounded. Once again an analysis of the Commonwealth War Graves database now records that four men were either killed or died of wounds on this day.

In the days following the attack, the battalion furnished carrying and burial parties, Colonel Wood departing the battalion on the 3rd suffering from shell shock, command now devolving on Major Hugh Delabere Bousfield D.S.O. After a further 5 O/R's were wounded on the latter date, the battalion marched to billets located in Martinsart and after providing further parties for the burial of the dead, orders were received to proceed to Hedauville, south-west of Forceville, at 4.30 p.m. on the afternoon of the 5th. Despite being shelled whilst departing the village, no casualties were sustained, Second-Lieutenant Joseph Bell? and William Pallister remaining behind in their appointed roles as Town Major of Martinsart and officer in charge of the Divisional Dump respectively.

The Leipzig Salient (Granatloch)

The 1/5th West Yorkshire's now set about a programme reorganisation and training but the respite from the trenches was to be of a short duration as on the 6th, Major Bousfield accompanied by Captain Pierce Mandeville and the now Adjutant, Walter Hanson Freeman, made a reconnaissance of trenches to the north of Thiepval "with a view to attack." As a consequence of these orders, the battalion now moved from Hedauville at 10 a.m. on the morning of the 7th to Martinsart Wood and here they remained in this position until the evening. Orders then stipulated that they were to take over positions in the Authuille Defences from the 25th Division, these positions being reached in driving rain by 1 a.m. on the morning of the 8th. About one hour later, they were then ordered up into the line to support two companies of the 3rd Battalion, Worcestershire Regiment of the 7th Infantry Brigade, 25th Division, the remaining companies of the Worcester's being withdrawn from the line during the mid morning.

There was now about to commence a long association with one key feature of the Thiepval battlefield by the 49th (West Riding) Division. Referred to by the German Army as the Granatloch, the British, the Leipzig Salient, this position, encompassing a quarry, had been gained at a hard cost by the 97th Infantry Brigade, 32nd Division, on the 1st July. One of just a few tentative gains established in the German trench system at Thiepval, the position was exposed and vulnerable to counter-attacks. After numerous attempts to expand the position, it was on the 7th July that both the 1st and 3rd Battalion's of the Wiltshire Regiment managed to exploit a footing gained in the enemy's front line position in the Salient, the Hindenburg Stellung, this being duly consolidated but at a severe cost to both battalion's. The enemy were determined to take the position back and push out the defenders of the Granatloch at all costs, the position itself and it's environs, becoming a charnel house for both attacker and defender alike.

The Leipzig Salient itself, in part, was located on a reverse slope, not directly visible from the west and the British front line positions of the 1st July. The southern aspect however covered all approaches from the south, west and east and offered excellent fields of fire. Some distance to the east of the position and situated on high ground to the north of Ovillers was the German position known as the Nordwerk. This dominating position, well sited, also had excellent observation over Nab Valley and had proved to be the nemesis of both the attacks of the 70th Infantry Brigade, 8th Division, and that of the 14th Infantry Brigade, 32nd Division, on the 1st July.

Despite the foothold gained in the Salient, the enemy still had in their possession a number of commanding trenches and positions to the north and north east,  the Lemberg Stellung, Turken Stellung and the Hohenzollern Stellung, the latter containing a fortified redoubt complete with dug-outs and also sited on a reverse slope, the Wundt Werk. The defenders however did possess some good points of observation in the line, particularly in the length of Hindenburg Stellung wrested from the enemy by the Worcester's on the 7th July. Two saps had been established from this position, "H" and "K" Saps respectively, these, offering excellent observation over the complete German support and reserve positions from the garrisoned buildings of Mouquet Farm to the heavily defended village of Pozieres further to the east.

The Granatloch itself contained several large dug-outs constructed to a deep depth with numerous exits and entrances. Fitted with electricity and well stocked with provisions, the old enemy front line to the west also contained numerous dug-outs and saps extending outwards into the former No Man's Land. Communication with the Old British Front Line was established by utilising a Sap (Sanda Sap), constructed by the 17th Northumberland Fusiliers, Pioneers to the 32nd Division, prior to the commencement of the Somme offensive. The Sap however had been blown in at various points and needed urgent improvements so as to assist in the movement of men and materiel into the captured position. To this end the men set about not only the improvement of the Sap, but also the trench system that had been virtually destroyed in many areas. It was inevitable that casualties would be sustained but how many would no doubt exceed all expectations.             

The Leipzig Salient
Extract Of Ovillers, Edition 3A, Sheet 57D, S.E.4. Trenches Corrected To 1/9/16
Holding The Salient
In driving rain, at about 2 a.m. on the morning of the 8th July, the men of the 1/5th West Yorkshire's set forth from the Authuille Defences. "B" and "C" Companies remaining in the latter defence system whilst "A" and "D" Companies now prepared to enter the Salient and associated trenches. With Battalion Headquarters being established at Campbell's Post, the relief was completed at around 6 a.m. but not without incident, Second-Lieutenant William Charles Seagar Prest and 6 Other Ranks being wounded and 1 O/R unfortunately killed. In addition to the presence of the 1/5th, the 1/7th Battalion, West Yorkshire Regiment (Leeds Rifles), Officer Commanding Lieutenant-Colonel Albert Edward Kirk V.D., had also received orders to proceed to the line from their positions in Aveluy Wood along with 6 mortars of the Brigade attached. Tasked with the relief of the 8th Battalion, Loyal North Lancashire Regiment also of the 7th Infantry Brigade, 25th Division, their relief was completed at about 6 a.m. No casualties are recorded in the War Diary of the 1/7th Battalion however an analysis of the CWGC database records that on the 8th, the battalion suffered 4 Other Ranks killed.
As both battalions took stock of their new surroundings, it soon became apparent that of paramount importance was the task of the repair of the trenches, the organisation of various stores and posts, and trenches dug in order to connect the Salient with the Old British Front Line. All day of the 9th was dedicated to these various tasks but the die was cast as the men were undertaking their labours with a further 4 O/Rs of the 1/5th being wounded. At 8 p.m., the 1/7th Battalion were relieved by the 1/6th Battalion, West Yorkshire Regiment, Officer Commanding, Lieutenant-Colonel Charles Edward Scott, whereupon the former battalion proceeded to the South Bluff, Authuille, near Black Horse Bridge (W.6.a.3.2.).
Orders issued to the 1/6th were spelt out in no uncertain terms the operational need as regards the position...."to be held at all costs."
Tempest's History of the Battalion records that the 1/6th moved to the Salient via Campbell Avenue and a recently dug trench across the former No Man's Land that was rather shallow in depth. The men were in fighting order minus pack and as they entered the position, they now became custodians of a large supply of Mills Bombs and Small Arms Ammunition. During the course of the relief, there was considerable enemy artillery fire resulting in 3 Other Ranks of the battalion being killed.
As the men continued to repair the trenches and consolidate the Old Front Line, "A" & "D" Companies of the 1/5th West Yorkshire's were relieved by "B" & "C" Companies respectively during the afternoon of the 10th. Once again, the battalion suffered numerous casualties during the course of the day, 1 man being killed and 15 O/R's being wounded. The pattern was similar during the following day with 1 man of the 1/6th killed and 4 O/R's of the 1/5th wounded as the German artillery continued to shell heavily both the Salient and the sector as a whole.
At 1.15 a.m. on the morning of the 12th July, the enemy would show his hand and launch an attack and attempt to break into the line. The exact nature of his enterprise is not recorded in substantial detail in both battalion's War Diaries however the Author, in part, will draw on Tempest's History Of The Sixth Battalion and the Brigade War Diary to explain events as they transpired.
It was at 11.30 p.m. on the night of the 11th July that the 1/6th Battalion had sent out a patrol consisting of two officers with scouts and bombers. It had been observed that during the course of the previous evening, the enemy had come out into No Man's Land from a Sap just to the north of the Salient, the objective of the patrol being to surround them and no doubt take prisoners. As the patrol lay out waiting, they were suddenly attacked and bombed at about 1.15 a.m. but somehow they managed to retire, fighting as they did so. At 1.30 a.m. a message was received at Brigade Headquarters from the O.C. 6th West Yorkshire's that his left Company Commander ("A" Company) reported that he was being driven back from his trenches by an enemy bombing attack on Sap "H" but it was quite fortuitous that during the course of the previous day, the 1/7th West Yorkshire's had brought up to the line thousands of Mills Bombs. The support company in the "crater" (Granatloch/Quarry) were at once immediately sent forward to reinforce this left company that was under attack, their support position in turn being taken over by the Reserve Company of the 6th West Yorks. The men had began to fire their S.O.S. rockets, a signal to initiate artillery fire on designated lines at 1.27 a.m., but due to the confusion of various signals fired by both attacker and defender, the supporting British artillery units did not bring their fire down until forty minutes after the commencement of the bombing attack (Tempest), 7 men of the 1/6th Battalion, West Yorkshire Regiment being killed whilst the enemy party attempted to breakthrough the line. Casualties to the 1/5th amounted to Second-Lieutenant John Victor Battersby Harford being wounded, Harford having only joined the battalion a few weeks previously, and 3 O/R's wounded.
With the 1/7th West Yorkshire's relieving the 1/6th Battalion on the night of the 12th/13th, two new officers joined the 1/5th Battalion on the 12th, Second-Lieutenants Cyril Goodwill and William Allan Banks. During the course of the following day, "A" & "D" Companies once again moved up into the line to relieve "B" & "C" Companies respectively. During this relief, Second-Lieutenant James Henry Armistead and 7 O/R's were wounded, a familiar pattern as the Granatloch 'consumed' yet more victims.
Fire Demonstration: 1/7th West Yorkshire's
It was at 2.15 a.m. on the morning of the 14th July that a barrage commenced on the enemy's positions, this being put down to assist a bombing attack that was to be launched by the 1/7th West Yorkshire's. With the 1/6th being brought forward in support with orders to consolidate the ground taken, "Zero" hour was set for 2.25 a.m. This operation, not only envisaged to expand the position to the north, would also detract German forces from the large scale attack being launched on the villages of Bazentin-le-Petit, Bazentin-le-Grand and Longueval by 8th and 15th Corps, Fourth Army.
Operation Orders stated that the 1/7th would attack with "A" and "B" Companies, three companies of the 1/6th attached and placed under the orders of the Officer Commanding the 1/7th, Lieutenant-Colonel Albert Edward Kirk V.D. Both the 1/5th, and the 1/8th Battalions would remain in their present positions, north-east of the Granatloch, and just to the west of Nab Valley between Lime Street and Mersey Street respectively in the event of a counter-attack. Headquarters of the 1/6th Battalion and 3 companies of the 148th Infantry Brigade would be placed in Reserve at the South Bluff, Authuille, under the orders of the Commanding Officer, 1/6th, Lieutenant-Colonel Charles Edward Scott.
Orders for the artillery were complex, but at 2.15 a.m., the artillery would open a "usual" barrage for a period of ten minutes and then at "Zero" in conjunction with the attack of the 1/7th, lift on to a line designated as "A," "E" & "D" for the duration of fifteen minutes. In basic terms, fire would be brought to bear on a designated line just to the south of Thiepval Village, south of this line, map references R.31.a & b, there was to be no barrage unless requested by the attacking infantry. To the north of Thiepval, a barrage would also be brought to bear stretching from a point just to the north of Mill Road, to the south of St. Pierre Divion, eastwards to a point near the Cemetery (references Q.24.d.7.7. - R.25.b.2.5.). After "Zero" hour, "Special Tasks" would be initiated, i.e. a bombardment that would be primarily fired at reference R.31.c. (directly north of the Granatloch and on the modern day line of the track leading from the Thiepval Memorial). The barrage would be performed by a variety of groups and various calibres of artillery from the 32nd and 49th Divisional Artillery augmented by attached French Artillery of the 37th and 20th Artillery Regiments and the 10th Corps Heavy Artillery.
To assist the attack, 1/8th West Yorkshire's would launch smoke ("P" Bombs) in conjunction with Number 1 Company Special Brigade, 5th Battalion, Royal Engineers from Mersey Street to Lime Street in an attempt to fill the Nab and its associated valley with smoke as far north as Mouquet Farm. The R.E. would deploy their smoke discharge from detachments of 4 inch Stokes Mortars, four guns under the command of Lieutenant Hugh Gordon Nourse on the right of the 146th Infantry Brigade and four guns under the command of Lieutenant William Harold Elliker on the left of the 147th Infantry Brigade who would discharge smoke up the Ancre valley. One hundred and twenty bombs would be allocated for each detachment deposited by either road or tramway as close as possible to the detachments positions, the time for the smoke discharge being set for 15 minutes before "Zero" hour. 
Leipzig Salient & Environs
146th Brigade Headquarters. T.N.A. WO95/2792/3

At "Zero" hour, the 1/7th West Yorkshire's launched their attack on the "A,"E" & "D" Line to the north of the Granatloch. One half of "B" Company proceeded forward towards the enemy lines up "A" & "B" Trench with the remaining half of the company advancing up "C" & "D" Trench respectively. Following behind this latter half company were one half of "A" Company, assigned the specific task of 'mopping up' the numerous enemy dug-outs located in the area of this sector of the advance. The remaining half of "A" Company would subsequently advance up "A" & "B" Trench with the objective of the occupation of the German trench system, whereupon, they would form a defensive line and consolidate the latter facing eastwards, no doubt forming 'trench blocks' to prevent any interdiction by enemy forces. With one company of the 1/6th West Yorkshire's assembled in the Crater/Granatloch with various quantities of trench materiel to assist in consolidation, one half of this company would follow on up "A" & "B" Trench, the remainder, proceeding forward up "C" & "D" Trench.
Accounts of the operation vary as does chronology but it would appear that from the outset, one party, moving over the open between "B" & "A" and "C" & "D" Trenches had met a large body of the enemy in both the open and in their trenches. Pushing this force back a distance of about 50 yards under a heavy bomb barrage, this party of "B" Company of the 1/7th West Yorkshire's became engaged in a ferocious bombing duel that eventually drove them back to their start point, the line "C" & "B" Trench, a message being received at Brigade Headquarters to this end timed at 3.10 a.m. 
The barrage was now requested to 'shorten,' i.e. to bring down fire on the rapidly advancing enemy force who were making good progress to the left of the failed attack. Companies were now reorganised as repeated requests were sent to the artillery to continue or alter their barrage as the attack developed yet further and as a consequence of mounting pressure, "C" & "B" Trench was subsequently abandoned. With nearly all of the Bombers of the 1/7th West Yorkshire's now either killed or wounded, two companies? of the 1/6th were now sent forward in an attempt to repel the counter-attack. Although "C" & "B" Trench had been abandoned, the position was defended to the last man by Bombers of the latter, greatly assisted by Stokes mortars and their crews who moved up into the open behind the British front line.

T.N.A. WO95/2792/3

The 1/5th West Yorkshire's now reported that the enemy counter-attack was developing yet further to the left at about 4.40 a.m., a verbal message being received to this effect at Brigade Headquarters. First hand accounts of the fighting are scarce, however the 1/6th Battalion Bombers, under the command of Lieutenant George Hargreaves Speight, gave a good account of themselves on this flank at Point "C" (Tempest's History). Lieutenant Hargreaves was awarded the Military Cross for his actions on this date, his citation in the London Gazette dated the 25th August 1916 reads as follows:-
"For conspicuous gallantry. When the enemy obtained a foothold in our front trench, occupied by another unit, he led his bombers with great dash and drove them out. On another occasion he drove off the enemy with bombs, inflicting heavy casualties."
Of the 1/7th, Lieutenant Frederick Joseph Baldwin was also awarded the M.C. His citation in the same edition of the London Gazette reads:-
" For conspicuous gallantry. When, at a critical moment his company commander was wounded, he took command, cleared away the wounded and organised the company to resist a counter-attack. He was wounded by a bullet in the leg, but stuck to his post and set a fine example."
At about 6.35 a.m. on the morning of the 15th, a message was received from the the front line reporting that it was "all quiet" despite the attentions of a few bombs, rifle grenades and trench mortar rounds. The Brigade War Diary records that the 1/7th West Yorkshire's had suffered 3 officers wounded and about 80 men either killed or wounded however the Battalion War Diary furnishes no details as to casualties sustained. An analysis therefore of the Commonwealth War Graves database now indicates that 1 Officer, Lieutenant Norman Wilson, and 20 men were killed or died of wounds in the attack. The 1/6th Battalion had suffered 4 men killed, and the 1/8th Battalion, one man, the indomitable Regimental Sergeant Major William Henry Fear M.C. In support positions to the north of the Granatloch, the 1/5th West Yorkshire's casualties numbered Second-Lieutenant Sidney Walker Birbeck and three O/R's wounded plus one man killed, Lance-Sergeant Arthur Boldison M.M., a native of York and a married man who was awarded the Military Medal posthumously in February 1917.
"Liquid Fire"
During the following day, the 1/5th West Yorkshire's set about repairing the trenches whilst the 1/6th Battalion took up station in the front line trenches. At about 3.30 a.m. (Brigade War Diary, 1/6th records 4 a.m.) on the morning of the 15th July just as dawn was beginning to break, an enemy bombing attack preceded by a heavy bombardment erupted along the length of the line. An alien sound was then heard followed by three jets of "liquid fire." Almost immediately an S.O.S. call was sent to the artillery followed by the firing of three red rockets in addition to a visual signal message being sent but the latter proved difficult to observe due to the misty conditions that prevailed. Two more sets of rockets were fired and a call was made from the artillery liason officer at 3.50 a.m. but it was not until six minutes later that the artillery responded and even then, the barrage was weak and far from adequate.
Once again the enemy were attempting to infiltrate the line on the left in the vicinity of "C" & "D" Trench/Sap and at 4.15 a.m. a further telephone call was made to the artillery followed by another rocket signal to increase their barrage. The Bombers of "B" Company, 1/6th West Yorkshire's, now became engaged in a bombing duel and to assist in the defence of the position, Lieutenant-Colonel Charles Edward Scott, O.C. 1/6th Battalion, now sent forward one platoon of the 1/7th Battalion who were in support in the Crater to reinforce the trench between Fifth Avenue (north-west of the Granatloch) and "C" & "D" Trench/Sap to support "B" Company.
Both the Brigade and the Battalion War Diaries record no specific details as to companies engaged but the Author surmises from various sources that the Battalion held the position as follows:-
"B" Company   Left Flank   O.C. Captain Eric Walter Knowles
"C" Company   Right Flank O.C. Captain Richard Alexander Fawcett M.C.
"A" Company   Centre        O.C. Captain Norman Muller
"D" Company   Support/Reserve   O.C. Temporary Captain John Lister Heselton (Wounded 1st July) 
Lieutenant Speight, "B" Company, was once again in the forefront of the action (see second part of M.C. citation) albeit slightly wounded. At 4.25 a.m., the centre company reported that "B" Company were holding the attack and that the machine gun on that flank withheld it's fire "against the possibility of the enemy succeeding in breaking through."
Colonel Scott received a message timed at 4.45 that the left flank company, "B," was "all right" and shortly afterwards the centre company reported its situation as the same. It soon became clear that the main thrusts of the enemy attack were, on the left down "C" & "D" Trench/Sap, eastwards down "B" & "A" Trench/Sap and "H" Trench/Sap. The whole action was characterised by the necessity for an adequate supply of bombs, this supply diminishing at an alarming rate throughout the course of the attack. To this end, the right flank bombing post, manned by "C" Company, received orders to forward bombs to "B" Company however Tempest's History records that Lieutenant Hornshaw (Frederick Geoffrey Hornshaw) of "C" Company replied that "his Bombs are not in Boxes, and that he is sending as many as he can, but he has only 400 Bombs left."
At this critical period and with the left flank coming under increasing pressure, Stokes mortars under the command of Captain Pike were brought forward and commenced a bombardment of the advancing enemy. Assisted by the 146th Brigade Machine Gun Company under the command of Captain John Muller, the effects of the mortar fire drove parties of the enemy into the open whereupon they were engaged at first by snipers and then by one machine gun under the command of Lance-Sergeant Harry Haigh,1927, the latter firing 1500 rounds with effective results.
It later transpired that the enemy force consisted of men of the 185th Infantry Regiment (185 Infanterie Regiment). An analysis of the action by Colonel Scott reported that "C" & "D" Trench was full of their dead however the defenders had learned costly lessons themselves. The necessity to have ample supplies of hand grenades begged numerous questions as to how many were actually adequate to deal with any prolonged assault. Although the Bombing Officer of the 1/6th West Yorkshire's was asked the specific question as to how many bombs were actually used in the defence of the line, no estimate was, or could be, provided. Scott himself recommended at the least a "couple of thousand boxes" but upon consultation with his aforementioned officer the latter deemed this to be "excessive." It was a fair point, bombs could be damaged or in the worst case scenario, a substantial dump could fall prey to the effects of enemy artillery. Yet another point to consider was the loss of experienced Bombers during the course of the attack, this, resulting in those who were untrained, throwing bombs without a correct setting adding to expenditure. In the case of Stokes mortar rounds, in excess of 400 mortar rounds were fired, the reserve of this ammunition, about 700 rounds, proving to be adequate.
Colonel Scott estimated his casualties during the action as two officers killed and one wounded (Lieutenant Speight). In Other Ranks, this estimate concluded that 3 had been killed and 30 wounded. An analysis therefore of the C.W.W.G database now indicates that the two officers killed were Second-Lieutenants Clarence Rueil Harper, "B" Company of Rawdon, near Leeds, and Richard Moore, "A" Company of Ripon, both officers now buried in adjoining graves in Blighty Valley Cemetery, Authuille Wood, Somme. In Other Ranks, the battalion suffered 8 men killed however two men are buried in cemeteries some distance behind the lines suggesting that they succumbed to wounds received previously. Amongst the dead was one Sergeant Joseph Sayers D.C.M., 2626, of "B" Company, a married man and a native of Bradford. Sayers, then a Private, had been awarded the Distinguished Conduct Medal for actions on the Canal Bank Sector at Ypres in 1915, his citation in the London Gazette dated the 22nd January 1916 reads:-
For conspicuous gallantry on the 19th November 1915, in the isolated trench known as the "Pump Room."
During a very heavy bombardment, when 6 men of the platoon were killed, 7 wounded and all the remainder more or less buried, Corporal Meekosha took command after all his seniors were killed or wounded, and commenced digging out the wounded in full view of the enemy and at short range from his trenches. By his gallant behaviour, and with the assistance of Privates Johnson, Sayers and Wilkinson, who stuck to him and most stoutly assisted him throughout, the lives of 4 men were saved."
Along with Sayer, Private Eli Johnson, 3225, and Private Edgar James Wilkinson, 1266, would also be awarded the Distinguished Conduct Medal, Wilkinson, being killed in action the following month aged 19 years. Corporal Samuel Meekosha, 1147, for his actions, would receive the highest award for gallantry, the Victoria Cross.
Commemoration Under Construction